latest

How astroturfing creates the illusion of authenticity and faux consensus.

latest experts

CAN YOU IDENTIFY PROPAGANDA?

Find out
Want to help us continue our work? All donations are tax deductible.
support this project

Full coverage of the 2022 Arizona U.S. Senate debate between Mark Kelly and Blake Masters.

By Grace Lovins and Charlotte Jones
10/30/2022 • 08:34 AM EST

Don't know how to use this page?

: Click or tap on any techniqueNull - the definition will be displayed here.
 that appears in bold to show its definition.
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Kelly has supported most Biden policies, he hasn't backed Biden every single time.[1]
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Masters once brought up social security privatization as an option for future generations, he never suggested doing it now.[2]
: common folkPropaganda Techniques - establishing a connection with an audience based on being just like one of them and therefore being able to empathize with their concerns.
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Masters once brought up social security privatization as an option for future generations, he never suggested doing it now.[2]
: half truthFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is essentially true, but lacking critical information and presented as the whole truth.
: Masters mentions Biden policies for giving rise to inflation, while ignoring the greater stimulus spending that occurred under Trump.[3]
: half truthFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is essentially true, but lacking critical information and presented as the whole truth.
: Masters mentions Biden energy policies for oil prices surging, while ignoring greater contributing factors like Covid and the war in Ukraine.[4]
: half truthFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is essentially true, but lacking critical information and presented as the whole truth.
: Masters mentions stimulus spending under Biden for giving rise to inflation, while ignoring the greater stimulus spending that occurred under Trump.[3]
: passing the buckDebate Techniques - shifting blame onto someone else for self-exoneration or to direct attention away from those really at fault.
: For inflation only to Covid, when many economists say the decision to flood the economy with stimulus money helped fuel inflation.[5]
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Masters once brought up social security privatization as an option for future generations, he never suggested doing it now.[2]
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Kelly has supported most Biden policies, he hasn't backed Biden every single time.[1]
: misleading claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement with a few elements or kernel of truth, which can easily be proven deceptive or fundamentally untrue.
: If the IRS uses the funds to hire new agents, it won't be immediate, but over 10 years, to replace 50,000 IRS agents who will be retiring.[6]
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: While Mark Kelly voted for stimulus checks under the American Rescue Plan, he never voted to send those checks to illegal aliens.[7]
: FUDPropaganda Techniques - making dire warnings or raising doubt about an issue, while provided little or no specifics or evidence to support the claims.
: Warning that all the IRS agents hired will be indiscriminately auditing everyone by this time next year.
: misleading claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement with a few elements or kernel of truth, which can easily be proven deceptive or fundamentally untrue.
: Kelly "said no" to a GOP proposed amendment that required hiring 18,000 border patrol agents before a single IRS agent could be hired.[8]
: exaggerationFalsehoods & Distortions - stretching the truth, to make something seem more powerful or meaningful than it actually is.
: While roughly $1 billion was granted for Customs and Border Protection, only about 10% went toward increasing border patrol agents.[6]
: misleading claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement with a few elements or kernel of truth, which can easily be proven deceptive or fundamentally untrue.
: Kelly voted against an amendment that required hiring 18,000 border patrol agents before a single IRS agent could be hired.[8]
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Record numbers of illegal aliens, when they come here, are arrested and over 1/3rd are deported.[9][10]
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Undocumented immigrants are not treated better than U.S. military service members.[11]
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Arrests along the southern border for 2022 are the highest ever recorded and about 36% of those crossing the border are deported.[9][10]
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Kelly's action taken while in office indicate he does not support open borders and has pushed Biden to do more.[12]
: guilt by associationPropaganda Techniques - using an opponent's links to another to assign the other's beliefs, misdeeds, or other unattractive qualities to the opponent.
: Masters uses the false claim that the border is "wide open" to link Kelly to terrorist narcos.
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Arrests along the southern border for 2022 are the highest ever recorded.[9][10]
: baseless claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is presented as accepted or established fact, but no evidence could be found to support the claim.
: 90% of border patrol agents would say they are disgusted with Mark Kelly.
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Arrests along the southern border for 2022 are the highest ever recorded.[9][10]
: false claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement that is directly contradicted by fact and can be easily proven untrue.
: Arrests along the southern border for 2022 are the highest ever recorded.[9][10]
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Masters does want a national abortion ban, even in cases of rape, the ban applies only to abortions after the 3rd trimester.[13]
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Kelly did sponsor a bill that would allow abortion up until the moment of birth, it would be only if the life of the mother is at risk.[14]
: guilt by associationPropaganda Techniques - using an opponent's links to another to assign the other's beliefs, misdeeds, or other unattractive qualities to the opponent.
: Masters uses Kelly's vote for the Women's Health Protection Act to link him to Warren, Sanders, AOC, China, and North Korea.
: projectionPropaganda Techniques - accusing an opponent of using the same underhanded tactics or committing the same misdeeds the accuser is guilty of.
: Masters, who just recently changed his radical positions on abortion, accuses Kelly of lying about his positions, while he accuses Kelly of being a radical on abortion.[15]
: red herringPropaganda Techniques - throwing an irrelevant fact into an argument to divert attention from the real issue at hand.
: Masters defends the positions he has on his website now, which have no relation to the positions he had on his website two months ago.[13]
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Kelly's legislation would allow abortion up until birth, it would be only if the life of the mother is at risk.[14]
: red herringPropaganda Techniques - throwing an irrelevant fact into an argument to divert attention from the real issue at hand.
: Masters brings up Arizona's 15-week law and Graham's bill on abortion, when both have no relation to the positions he held on abortion two months ago.[13]
: ad hominemPropaganda Techniques - attacking the character or motive of the person making an argument, rather than attacking the argument itself.
: Kelly attacks Masters' character, while not challenging the merits of his positions.
: straw manFalsehoods & Distortions - misrepresenting an opponent's position or argument to make it easier to attack, usually by exaggerating, distorting, or just completely fabricating it.
: While Kelly's policy would allow abortion up until birth, it would be only if the life of the mother is at risk.[14]
: misleading claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement with a few elements or kernel of truth, which can easily be proven deceptive or fundamentally untrue.
: The FBI warned Facebook and other big tech companies about amplifying Russian disinformation before the election and played no direct role in suppressing the Hunter Biden story.[16][17]
: misleading claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement with a few elements or kernel of truth, which can easily be proven deceptive or fundamentally untrue.
: The FBI didn't "work with" big tech and big media to censor the Hunter Biden laptop story. Big tech did that independently.[16][17]
: misleading claimFalsehoods & Distortions - a statement with a few elements or kernel of truth, which can easily be proven deceptive or fundamentally untrue.
: The FBI was not "working with" big tech or the media and played no direct role in suppressing the Hunter Biden story. Big tech did that independently.[16][17]
: honor by associationPropaganda Techniques - championing cultural sacred cows to assume the respect, authority, sanction, and prestige of those symbols.
: Veterans, the military.
: appeal to compromised authorityFalsehoods & Distortions - insisting something is true because an expert on the issue says it's true, when that expert has a vested interest in the outcome.
: 57% of Arizona vets and 72% of active duty military support Masters, according to his own "latest internal polling."
: appeal to traditionPropaganda Techniques - suggesting that a long-standing practice must be better than newer alternatives and that abandoning it could have detrimental implications.
: Of using gender pronouns strictly according to someone's assigned sex at birth.

Total number of techniques detected over the 56:53 runtime of this video clip:

PROPAGANDA TECHNIQUES

10 OCCURRENCES

ad hominem:  
appeal to tradition:  
common folk:  
FUD:  
guilt by association:    
honor by association:  
projection:  
red herring:    

FALSEHOODS & DISTORTIONS

29 OCCURRENCES

appeal to compromised authority:  
baseless claim:  
exaggeration:  
false claim:                
half truth:      
misleading claim:            
straw man:                  

SUMMARY

39 OCCURRENCES

Masters: 75%
Kelly: 23%
Viktor: 3%

References
1. "Mark Kelly's breaks with Biden pile up". Politico. Published: April 05, 2022.

2. "Blake Masters “wants to privatize” Social Security.". Politifact. Published: October 28, 2022.

3. "Fact-checking Republican attempts to blame inflation on Democrats". CNN Politics. Published: August 06, 2021.

4. "Republicans Wrongly Blame Biden for Rising Gas Prices". The New York Times. Published: March 09, 2022.

5. "Rapid Inflation Fuels Debate Over What’s to Blame: Pandemic or Policy". The New York Times. Published: January 22, 2022.

9. "Arrests along U.S.-Mexico border top 2 million a year for the first time". Texas Tribune. Published: September 19, 2022.

13. "VERIFY: Where does Blake Masters stand on abortion?". KPNX-TV 12 News. Published: August 16, 2022.